Sunday, November 13, 2011

Love Might Be Too Strong a Word

The short story, "Love Might be too Strong a Word," created a setting in which gender did not remain within our own binary concepts. However, I noticed during class that we seemed to be unable to attempt to assign each of the newly introduced genders a binary form. For instance, we assumed that if someone had parts described as "outie" parts, we automatically assumed that person was to be masculine. We also made an assumption that, should someone's gender pronouns end in a similar fashion to "him" or "her," they should keep with our perceptions of male and female.
It was interesting to note this, especially since our class is meant to study the queer within literature. It was indeed quite queer to read a story that created new genders. But it was more interesting to see how difficult it was too discard society's standards of male and female. Regardless of how open-minded each of us in class is, in our discussion, we still struggled to use the proper pronouns instead of "he" and "she."
It might have been difficult to discard these roles simply because of the roles we were shown. It seemed that any character we assumed was male had a leadership position and was generally above the strictly "female" (by our standards) characters, the dailys. Any character to whom the maintenance and less desirable tasks were left was perceived as female.
I also found it interesting that this story showed us a character that went against its gender roles in most aspects of the society. Mab did adhere to gender roles if yr job is taken into account, because y worked as a cleaner, as all the other dailys did. However, Mab became the more bossy member of the relationship between Dot and Mab, even deciding how they would interact sexually. This would be, typically, a task left up to the pilots, but Mab chose to take this over.

8 comments:

  1. Could our society exist without gender?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I smiled internally when in a previous discussion in comments Peter said "I wonder if there exists a story with a protagonist who is neither female or male." I didn't want to spoil the surprise then, but indeed, there do exist such stories. We've now looked at two of them.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I liked that this story went against gender roles it made it more interesting to read

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think it is very difficult for anyone to talk about a human or animal without giving it a gender. Our society is simply not progressive enough to drop those roles, as they have been engraved in our brains from day one, and society has been quite separated in terms of gender for as long as there have been humans. Yes, there are stories like these that create different genders and we subsequently have difficulties with them. However, generally speaking these new genders also have their own set of roles that they are "supposed to conform to". I think the most progressive part of this story is exactly as you said, Mab taking on the more dominant role over a pilot in their sexual relationship.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I actually strongly agree with what Jessica said. She brought up a really good point about how the characters did fit into the norms set for society that I did not realize until she mentioned it. I think that we are programmed to associate things with gender on an everyday basis. It will take a very long time if ever to disregard gender because we have taken it so deeply into our existence. I think that the fact that we challenge it with texts like this is amazing because it makes you realize the way you look at things in a everyday routine.

    ReplyDelete
  6. It's a pity gender is so important in our society.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I don't think we will ever get rid of gender roles.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Gender roles are always going to be around. its a fact

    ReplyDelete